Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) has stopped listing the locations of detainees with final orders of removal on its public online locator, a move that has drawn criticism from immigration advocates and legal groups who say it hampers families and attorneys seeking to locate those in custody.
Explainer The Pro-Life Movement’s Legal Landscape: Abortion Battles and State Sovereignty
The policy shift has intensified debate over transparency and due process in immigration enforcement, as states that have banned ICE from local jails now face detainee transfers to distant facilities.
The change, first reported by The New York Times and the Associated Press, follows years of state-level efforts to restrict ICE’s use of local detention centers. In 2021, Illinois Governor J.B. Pritzker signed a law ending county jail contracts with ICE, prompting the agency to transfer detainees to other states by early 2022. Maryland’s legislature also pushed ICE out of local jails, resulting in three out of four people detained after arrests in Maryland being held in Texas, Louisiana, or Mississippi, according to a Capital News Service analysis of ICE records. New Jersey enacted a similar ban in 2021, though a federal appeals court struck it down last year.
ICE’s Policy Change
ICE’s online locator, launched in 2010 as a courtesy, is not required by statute. The agency recently removed thousands of detainees with final removal orders from the public database, including more than 20,000 people, according to a lawsuit filed by the National Immigration Law Center and other groups. The Department of Homeland Security provided contractors with a script to explain to callers that this information is no longer public, The New York Times reported.
Lawyers and advocates argue that the policy makes it difficult to track clients and provide timely legal representation. Cassandra Charles, senior staff attorney at the National Immigration Law Center, said, “The government is trying to deport immigrants as quickly as possible, and disappearing people from the system helps accomplish that by making it very difficult for family members and attorneys to find people.”
ICE officials and former agency leaders counter that all detainees can contact family or legal counsel, and that the locator was never intended as a legal requirement. Scott Mechkowski, a retired ICE deputy field office director, wrote that “nobody has disappeared. ICE knows where every person in its custody is, and every detainee can pick up a phone and call a family member or a lawyer.”
State Bans and Detainee Transfers
The removal of detainees from the public database has coincided with increased transfers of people in the country illegally from states that have banned ICE contracts. When local jails in Illinois, Maryland, and New Jersey ended their agreements, ICE moved detainees to facilities in Louisiana, Texas, and Mississippi. Officials in those states have since criticized the agency for relocating detainees far from their families.
Public protests have erupted outside detention centers in sanctuary states, including New Jersey and California, with activists and some local officials accusing ICE of “disappearing” or “kidnapping” detainees. In Newark, New Jersey, a protest outside Delaney Hall led to more than 80 arrests after demonstrators attempted to block ICE vehicles. Governor Mikie Sherrill deployed state police to clear the area, citing concerns about giving ICE a “pretext to expand operations.”
"When a governor, a mayor, or a newspaper calls a lawful arrest a kidnapping, they are telling people those officers are criminals and that stopping them is justified. That is how officers get hurt."
— Scott Mechkowski, retired ICE deputy field office director
Legal and Political Reactions
A lawsuit filed in federal court in Boston by the National Immigration Law Center and other organizations alleges that ICE’s new policy is unlawful and has caused more than 20,000 detainees to disappear from the public database. Lawyers say the lack of transparency can have “life-altering and devastating” consequences for detainees and their families.
ICE officials and supporters argue that the agency is enforcing laws passed by Congress and that state and local leaders who ban ICE from their jails are responsible for the resulting transfers and disruptions. Mechkowski wrote, “If these leaders want detainees held closer to home, they can let ICE back into their jails.”
While critics continue to press for greater transparency and oversight, ICE has not indicated any plans to reverse the policy. The agency maintains that detainees’ locations are known internally and that legal counsel can still reach clients through established channels.
The Department of Homeland Security and ICE have not publicly addressed the specific criticisms raised by legal groups and activists regarding the locator policy.


