The U.S. Supreme Court is set to hear arguments on December 2 in two consolidated cases that challenge state and local bans on AR-15-style rifles, a decision that could affect gun laws in 11 states and the District of Columbia.
Explainer Second Amendment Rights and Federal Courts: Balancing Liberty and Regulation
The outcome will determine whether states and localities can prohibit the most popular modern semiautomatic rifles in the country, or if such bans violate constitutional rights.
The cases, Viramontes v. Cook County and Grant v. Higgins, target longstanding bans in Cook County, Illinois, and Connecticut. Both laws restrict the possession, sale, and transfer of AR-15s and similar rifles. Connecticut’s ban was enacted in 2013 after the Sandy Hook Elementary School shooting, while Cook County’s ordinance dates to 1993 and has been updated several times, including after the 2007 shooting death of Blair Holt.
What the Supreme Court Will Decide
The justices will consider whether the Second and Fourteenth Amendments guarantee the right to possess AR-15 platform and similar semiautomatic rifles. Plaintiffs, including the Second Amendment Foundation, argue that these rifles are in “common use” for lawful purposes and cannot be banned. Bill Sack, the foundation’s legal director, said the core question is whether governments can "ban the most popular modern semi-automatic rifles in the country."
"The Supreme Court, by deciding this issue, will finally put to bed whether or not these bans can even exist."
— Adam Kraut, Second Amendment Foundation executive director
Gun rights advocates cite Supreme Court precedents such as Heller and Bruen, which protect firearms in common use, and argue that only weapons that are both "dangerous and unusual" may be restricted. They contend that tens of millions of Americans own AR-15s for self-defense, hunting, and recreation, and that these rifles are legal in most states.
Political and Legal Stakes
The timing of the Supreme Court’s review comes as several newly elected Democrats have campaigned on enacting a federal ban on AR-15s and similar rifles. Forty-one Senate Democrats co-sponsored the Assault Weapons Ban of 2025. In Virginia, a new state ban was challenged by the Department of Justice earlier this year.
A ruling upholding state and local bans could encourage more legislatures to enact similar restrictions. Adam Kraut of the Second Amendment Foundation warned that "more legislatures would potentially be banning and limiting Americans’ selection of arms. It doesn’t just stop with this."
What the Connecticut Brief Argues
In its Supreme Court brief, Connecticut’s attorney general asserts that the AR-15 ban is "consistent with our nation’s long history of regulating such weapons." The brief details how the law, updated in 2013, prohibits semiautomatic, centerfire rifles with features such as folding stocks or pistol grips, and specifically bans the AR-15 and Bushmaster Model XM15. The state argues that AR-15s are "unusually dangerous and excessively lethal," and that the law preserves legal avenues for self-defense and other lawful purposes. The brief states: "There is no meaningful debate that AR-15s are unusually dangerous," and highlights their disproportionate use in mass shootings and killings of law enforcement officers.
The Second Circuit upheld Connecticut’s law in August 2025, finding that the Second Amendment right to keep and bear arms is "not unlimited" and that the state’s restrictions are "entirely consistent with the nation’s historical tradition of firearm regulations."
Oral arguments in both Viramontes v. Cook County and Grant v. Higgins are scheduled for December 2. A decision is expected next summer.


