Youngkin Directs Virginia Health Board to Regulate Transgender Participation in Women's Sports

Virginia Governor Glenn Youngkin has directed the state’s health board to create regulations aimed at protecting women’s sports and locker rooms from participation by individuals identifying as transgender. This directive, issued on Thursday, underscores ongoing debates surrounding gender identity and safety in educational environments.

Explainer Youngkin Orders Criminal Investigation Into Alleged Abortion Funding in Virginia Schools

In a statement, Youngkin expressed concern over the safety of women and girls in sex-segregated spaces, stating, "The health and safety of women and girls in sex separated spaces and participating in athletic competitions is in serious jeopardy due to irresponsible policies." He emphasized the need for regulations that prevent males from participating in female-only sports and using designated female spaces.

The governor's executive order tasks the Virginia Board of Health (BOH) with adopting new regulations under the Administrative Process Act. These regulations would specifically prohibit individuals who identify as transgender from competing on female athletic teams and utilizing spaces where females may be undressed.

This directive appears to be a response to a petition submitted in August by three female athletes, who requested the BOH to amend existing regulations to address these concerns. Youngkin noted that the BOH plans to publish a Notice of Intended Regulatory Action (NOIRA) regarding this regulation.

The issue has gained traction amid several incidents in Northern Virginia schools that have raised alarms about safety and privacy. In mid-August, Loudoun County Public Schools suspended two students after they questioned the presence of a transgender-identifying female in the boys’ locker room. The U.S. Department of Education later determined that the school district had violated Title IX and retaliated against the students, leading to a resolution agreement.

Additionally, a recent complaint filed in Fairfax County alleges that a male observed girls undressing in a women’s locker room at West Springfield High School. Reports indicate that when a student raised concerns, faculty members stated they could not take action.

Fairfax County has also faced scrutiny for its handling of a case involving Richard Cox, a Tier III sex offender, who was not charged after allegedly exposing himself in local recreational facilities. Critics argue that the county's inaction reflects broader issues regarding the safety of women and girls in public spaces.

The governor's directive has sparked a range of reactions. Supporters argue that the regulations are necessary to ensure the safety and privacy of female athletes and students. Critics, however, contend that such measures could infringe on the rights of transgender individuals and further stigmatize them.

Youngkin's actions come as Virginia approaches its gubernatorial election, with early voting having begun on September 19 and Election Day set for November 4. The race features Republican Lt. Gov. Winsome Earle-Sears against former Democratic Rep. Abigail Spanberger, with the issue of transgender participation in sports becoming a focal point of the campaign.

Spanberger has faced criticism for her stance on the issue, having previously declined to condemn policies that allow transgender individuals access to women’s spaces. She did not respond to inquiries regarding her position on the recent incidents or the governor's directive.

As the debate continues, the Virginia Board of Health is expected to move forward with the regulatory process, which could have significant implications for the state's approach to gender identity in schools and sports.