Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer, D-N.Y., is navigating a challenging landscape as Congress approaches a potential government shutdown. With funding set to expire on September 30, the dynamics of the negotiations reveal a lack of leverage for Schumer and Senate Democrats, according to a recent memo from the think tank Third Way.
Explainer Senate Democrats Block Confirmation of 10 U.S. Attorneys
The Third Way memo, released in mid-September, suggests that Democrats may be in a precarious position. It states, "this is the rare shutdown fight in which the policy, politics, and leverage all align" for Democrats. However, it also proposes that if Republicans wish to continue their efforts to change health care policies, they should pursue funding through a partisan budget reconciliation process.
this is the rare shutdown fight in which the policy, politics, and leverage all align
Reconciliation allows for certain budgetary measures to pass with a simple majority, bypassing the usual filibuster in the Senate. This means that if Republicans unite, they could potentially fund the government without Democratic support. The memo's contradictory messages have raised questions about the Democrats' strategy and their actual standing in the negotiations.
Jim Kessler, Third Way’s policy head and a former aide to Schumer, has been noted for his insights into the current political climate. He emphasized that the memo reflects an understanding among Democrats that they may not have the upper hand in this funding battle. "The reference to reconciliation is the only sentence in that five-page memo that matters," Kessler stated, indicating that the Democrats are aware of their limited options.
The reference to reconciliation is the only sentence in that five-page memo that matters,
Critics argue that the suggestion for Republicans to use reconciliation undermines the Democrats' negotiating position. They contend that it would allow Republicans to avoid a public confrontation, thereby enabling Democrats to save face with their political base. "If Republicans don’t need Democrat votes, then Senate Democrats won’t be forced into an embarrassing surrender," said Chris Jacobs, founder and CEO of Juniper Research Group.
The potential for a government shutdown looms large as both parties grapple with the implications of funding negotiations. Republicans have expressed skepticism about the feasibility of passing a comprehensive spending bill through reconciliation, citing procedural hurdles and the need for consensus among party members.
"Funding the entire federal government via budget reconciliation raises all manner of procedural difficulties," Jacobs noted. He added that many Republican members of the Appropriations Committees would likely object to such a move, fearing a loss of power.
As the deadline approaches, the stakes are high for both parties. Democrats face pressure from their base to protect health care funding, while Republicans are wary of the implications of a shutdown. The outcome of these negotiations could have lasting effects on both parties as they prepare for the upcoming election cycle.
In summary, the Third Way memo highlights a critical moment for Schumer and Senate Democrats as they confront a potential government shutdown. With Republicans potentially able to fund the government independently, the Democrats' strategy and leverage are under scrutiny as the deadline approaches.
Why it matters
- Senate Democrats face a precarious position as funding expiration nears, with limited leverage in negotiations against Republicans.
- The Third Way memo suggests Republicans could bypass Democrats using budget reconciliation, complicating the funding battle.
- Democrats are under pressure to protect health care funding, while Republicans are cautious about the implications of a shutdown.
What’s next
- Congress must reach a funding agreement by September 30 to avoid a government shutdown.
- Senate Democrats may need to reassess their strategy as negotiations progress and the deadline approaches.